CharlieHR
BambooHR
Timetastic
Papershift
Rotageek
Factorial
Best for
Small businesses under 30
Midsize businesses with HR teams
Teams that only need leave tracking software
Timesheets
Growing European SMBs
Workforce planning
Pricing
From £20/month (£5 for <4 team members)
From £8.10/employee (sales-led)
From £1.20 per user per month
From £5 per employee per month, plus a £39 per month basic fee
From £5.40 per user per month (sales-led)
Not publicly available
Setup time
Under 1 week (avg 3 days)
4-6 weeks
Under 1 week
Under 1 week
Not publicly available
4-6 weeks
Ease of use
(G2 rating)
9.6
9.2
9.6
Not available
9.1
9.3
Features available
Employee self-service
✅
✅
✅
✅
✅
✅
Automated leave requests and approvals
✅
✅
✅
✅
✅
✅
Custom leave types
✅
✅
✅
✅
✅ As an add-on
✅
Rota / shift management
❌
✅ As an add-on
❌
✅ On some plans
✅
✅
Timesheets
❌
✅ As an add-on
❌
✅
✅ As an add-on
✅
Automatic calculations
✅
✅
✅
✅
✅
✅
Team calendars
✅
✅
✅
✅
✅
✅
Audit trail and reporting
✅
✅
✅
✅ On some plans
✅
✅
Absence trends
✅
✅
✅ On some plans
✅ On some plans
✅
✅
Compliance (UK/EU)
✅
✅
✅
✅
✅
✅
Integrations with payroll and HR
✅
✅
❌
✅ Including integration with CharlieHR
✅
✅
All-in-one HR platform
✅
✅
❌
❌
✅
❌
Customer support
Email, chat
Phone, email, chat
Email
Phone, chat
Phone, email
Phone, chat
Free trial
✅ 7 days
✅ 7 days
✅ 30 days
✅ 7 days
✅ After live demo
❌
Best for team size
1-30
100-500+
30-100
30-100+
100-500+
400+

CharlieHR (also known as Charlie) is the ideal HR software for small businesses that want to replace spreadsheets, emails, and manual work. Founders, CEOs, and managers can use Charlie for leave management and other areas of HR, including onboarding, performance reviews, and employee data management.
Of course we think Charlie is the best, but here’s why it’s the right leave management system for small businesses:
See who’s working and who isn’t at a glance — Use the team and company calendars to plan workloads, client meetings, and project deadlines.
Automate the annual leave booking system — Employees can submit a request, the system checks for clashes, and managers can approve quickly.
Introduce custom leave types — Offer options that match your ways of working, like menstrual leave or duvet days
Stay compliant with statutory leave requirements — Automatic calculations provide you with the right leave entitlements and balances for every employee.
Securely store records of annual leave and holiday pay — Meet your legal obligations by keeping records in line with the 6-year requirement.
Integrate with other tools you use — Easy integrations with payroll tools like Xero and PayCaptain, or rota planning software like Papershift.
(as of May 2026)
👍
Ideal for small businesses looking for their first HR software (including leave management).
👍
Perfect if you have no HR experience or are part of a small HR team.
👍
Easy to set up and use.
❌
No built-in rota planning feature, but you can integrate with Papershift to add this functionality.
❌
Not recommended for large organisations with complex needs.
Charlie’s pricing works in brackets where the price increases as your team size grows, starting from as little as £20 per month. There’s one simple plan that includes all the features. We offer a competitive price for small businesses: £5 per month for up to 4 team members for the first six months, representing a 75% discount.
Choose Charlie if you’re looking for an easy to use, affordable, and beginner-friendly annual leave management software.
BambooHR works best for medium-to-large sized businesses that need a platform that supports more complex needs and leave management on a bigger scale.
BambooHR includes leave management and other core HR features, with the option to upgrade plans to add more functionality around employee experience and growth. It’s a comprehensive platform, but can be overcomplicated and expensive for small businesses, leading them to seek out BambooHR alternatives:
See who’s working and who isn’t at a glance — Use the team and company calendars to plan workloads, client meetings, and project deadlines.
Automate the annual leave booking system — Employees can submit a request, the system checks for clashes, and managers can approve quickly.
Customise your policies — Update the system to match your internal policies on time off, holidays, and sickness.
See who’s working — Use the built-in calendar to check whether someone is working or not, to avoid holiday clashes.
Make it easy for employees to clock in — Introduce a simpler and faster way for employees to check in.
Export data to your chosen payroll system — Download a spreadsheet for easier payroll preparation.
👍
Good for companies with a dedicated HR team that can take advantage of the range and depth of features.
👍
Suitable for global employment and compliance across different countries.
👍
Includes an AI assistant.
❌
Pricing is often unaffordable for small businesses — especially very small teams.
❌
Can be too complex for small businesses (according to customers who switched from BambooHR to Charlie).
BambooHR’s pricing plans aren’t detailed online, but their website confirms that pricing starts at £8.10 per employee per month. Teams can choose from three plans — Core, Pro, or Elite.
Choose BambooHR if you have an in-house HR manager or team and want to handle leave management at scale.
Timetastic is a standalone staff leave and holiday management tool, so it’s ideal for businesses that don’t need a complete HR system or more advanced features.
Timetastic’s simple interface and calendar-style approach to managing time off works well for small businesses, but the lack of other core HR functionality means you’d also need to invest in another tool for HR management:
Book leave wherever you are — Let team members request leave from desktop or the mobile app.
See who’s working and when — Get a clear view of absences with a colourful calendar view.
Simplify time off approvals — Easily see who is requesting time off, when, and why, then approve with one click.
Track holiday and leave allowances — Let the software automatically calculate balances.
Stay informed of upcoming leave — Get a digest of who’s on leave now and in the next week.
Encourage employees to use their time off — Get notifications about unused leave that’s about to expire.
👍
Automatic, detailed leave summaries and allowance notifications.
👍
Highly visual time planning calendar.
👍
Includes an AI assistant.
❌
Accrued leave is only an option if you upgrade to Timetastic Pro.
❌
Works as a standalone leave management tool so you’d need another system to handle HR — like an HRIS (HR Information System).
Timetastic’s pricing starts at £1.20 per employee per month for their basic plan, with the option to upgrade to Timetastic Pro to unlock absence trends, burnout risk alerts, and integrations.
Choose Timetastic if you only need absence tracking and want a simple approach.
Papershift is a tool dedicated to rota and timesheet management, which means it works best for small businesses that already have an HR system but need more specific rota support.
Papershift’s platform combines time tracking and roster scheduling with absence management and personnel files in a way that’s great for retail and hospitality businesses:
Set leave entitlements — Assign entitlements and balances to employees in line with labour compliance.
View team absences — Use the built-in calendar to see planned and current absences.
Create automated rota schedules — Fill your rota in a few clicks based on employee availability and leave requests.
Get real-time insights into who’s working — Use the built-in time clock app to verify when team members check in and out.
Approve timesheets with one click — Save managers’ time with easy timesheet approvals.
Prevent leave on key dates — Block out dates where employees can’t block leave to prevent holidays that conflict with events or deadlines.
👍
Easy time tracking and timesheet management.
👍
Automatic rota management to save time on building manual schedules.
👍
Clear visibility into planned holidays to support easier work planning.
❌
Designed for teams that need rota and shift support — if that’s not you, another tool would work better.
❌
Only suitable for time, rota, and absence management, so you’d need another tool for core HR.
Papershift’s pricing starts at £5 per month per employee, plus a £39 per month basic fee. Teams can choose to upgrade to the Premium or Professional plan for extra functionality.
Choose Papershift if you need timesheets and rota management.
Factorial is an all-in-one HR platform that combines time management, talent management, finance, and payroll, making it a good option for businesses that want to centralise all these operations in one place.
With a European headquarters and focus, Factorial supports UK and EU compliance well, but it’s a better fit for those medium-sized businesses that either have a presence in mainland Europe or plan to:
Get visibility on working locations — Monitor who is working from which location, whether you’re in-person, hybrid, or remote.
Built for compliance — Keep track of breaks, working hours, and leave, and tailor policies based on your employee’s location.
Manage time tracking — Create, approve, or reject timesheets in a few clicks to save employees and managers time.
Introduce better shift management — Detect scheduling conflicts, assign shifts, and use analytics to improve shift selection over time.
Add custom leave types — Customise the settings for your different leave types so they align with your policies.
Sync overtime data with payroll — Make sure every employee’s pay is correct with overtime that’s automatically reflected in exports for payroll.
👍
Includes timesheets and shift scheduling.
👍
Core HR provision that you can customise with modules for talent management, finance, and payroll.
👍
Designed for a European audience.
❌
The price per employee may put this software outside the budget range of many small businesses.
❌
Some features, like custom leave types and timesheets, are only available as paid add-ons.
Factorial’s pricing starts at £5.40 per user per month, with tailored quotes available on request. Plans include Factorial Core, and teams can choose to add modules for a custom experience.
Choose Factorial if you’re based in or plan to expand into Europe, and want the flexibility to personalise your plan with different add-ons and modules.
Rotageek is a workforce management platform, so it’s ideal for businesses that need to plan rotas and schedules for a large number of people or teams.
Although it’s designed for large and enterprise-level businesses, Rotageek might be a suitable option if you’re growing fast and want a system that can scale with you — especially if you work in retail, hospitality, leisure, or healthcare:
Forecast labour demand — Plan schedules based on how much support you’ll need, using analytics to predict the future.
Set your own leave rules — Add rules and policies and have them applied automatically based on your requirements.
Create schedules quickly — Introduce digital schedules that can be updated on the fly as demand or priorities change.
See real-time attendance data — Make swifter decisions and find replacements more easily with access to live information.
Schedule team members appropriately — Make sure you’re fulfilling contractual commitments by scheduling people based on contracted hours and preferences.
Use AI to get deeper insights — Ask questions, prompt the system to create fair schedules, and use the data in reports to optimise future work plans.
👍
Intelligent shift, rota, and workforce planning.
👍
Customisable leave policies and processes, based on your rules.
👍
Built-in AI assistant that can gather insights and optimise schedules.
❌
Designed for large and enterprise-level businesses, so it’s less suitable for small teams.
❌
Level of complexity and depth may be a challenge for business owners, especially if they scale fast.
Rotageek doesn’t list pricing on their website, but you can book a demo with the team to share your requirements and request more information.
Choose Rotageek if you need intelligent workforce planning and you plan to expand rapidly.
Software
Starting price
Pricing model
What’s included
Hidden costs
Best value for
CharlieHR
£5/month for first 6 months (up to 4 team members) then from £20/month
Bracket pricing by team size
Onboarding, time off, HR policies, document storage, and more
All features are included
Very small businesses (1-30 team members)
BambooHR
From £8.10 per employee per month
Quote (sales led)
Core HR, onboarding, employee database and more
Different packages for different inclusions
Midsize businesses (100+ employees)
Timetastic
From £1.20 per user per month
Per employee
Time off management, work schedules
Different packages for different inclusions
Small businesses (30-100 team members)
Papershift
From £5 per employee per month, plus a £39 per month basic fee
Per employee
Time tracking, roster scheduling, absence management, onboarding, offboarding, payroll, personnel files
Different packages for different inclusions
Small to medium sized businesses (30-100+ employees)
Factorial
From £5.40 per user per month (sales-led)
Per user
Time management, payroll, talent management, IT management, finance
Not publicly available
Medium to large sized businesses (100-500+ employees)
Rotageek
Not publicly available
Not publicly available
Shift management, leave management, time tracking, timesheets
Not publicly available
Large businesses with multi-site operations (400+ employees)
Yasmin Lord-Pottinger, People and Talent Lead at CharlieHR, shares a good way for you to see if you’ll get the right return on investment: “Let’s say you or your team spend roughly 2 hours a week on leave management, at an average total cost of £33 per hour (salary + NI + overheads) and 46 working weeks in a year, that’s 2 hours × £33 × 46 weeks = £3,063. It quickly becomes obvious that you’ll need HR software” – simply work out the math for yourself, and you’ll see how much you can get from HR software that includes leave management.
Automated leave requests and approvals so it’s no longer a manual task on someone’s to-do list
UK statutory leave configuration out of the box instead of as a custom workaround, so you can support compliance from day one
Team absence calendar that gives visibility to managers and the wider team
Self-service access for employees so they’re not chasing someone every time they want to book a day off
Audit trail and reporting for compliance and dispute resolution
Integration with payroll and HR so you’re simplifying processes, not making them more complicated
Integration with payroll and HR so you’re simplifying processes, not making them more complicated
Simple setup with no IT team required
1.
Figure out what you want from leave management, including your top 3-5 requirements
2.
List the problems you have right now and how software can help solve them
3.
Set a budget based on what you can realistically afford
4.
Do your research using a mix of sources, including review guides, search engines, LLMs, and peers
5.
Book a demo and come prepared with specific questions
6.
Test the software for free
7.
Review your experience
8.
Ask for support if you need to convince people internally to invest in the software
9.
Make the decision that’s right for you
Some advice from Josh Hardy, sales manager at CharlieHR: “Don’t be scared to drill down on the questions. A sales rep is here for that, and they should also be able to support you to sell your case internally, so always ask for more and see how they can help you. Ultimately, you shouldn’t feel alone in your research.”
For small businesses with under 30 people, CharlieHR is easy to use, supports compliant processes, and offers plenty of value with more features than dedicated leave management tools. For larger teams with more complex needs, consider BambooHR. If your focus is rota or shift management, consider Papershift or Rotageek.
Book a demo to see if CharlieHR is right for you.
The cost of employee leave management software depends on the number of features, whether it’s a standalone tool or a broader HR system, and who it’s aimed at. Based on our research, HR leave management software can cost between £1.20 and £8.10 per employee per month.
Workers in the UK are entitled to a statutory minimum of 5.6 weeks of paid annual leave per year. For full-time workers, this works out at 28 paid days of leave per year. Our holiday calculator can help you work out the entitlement for part-time workers or those with irregular or seasonal working hours. Bank holidays don’t have to be given as paid leave — employers can choose whether to include these as part of a worker’s statutory leave or not.
You can manage leave in a spreadsheet, but it’s not recommended. Using a spreadsheet leaves you open to human error and miscalculations, and can lead to data not being properly recorded or tracked. Read our guide on HR software vs. spreadsheets for more reasons to make the switch.
Getting annual leave entitlements or calculations wrong can lead to Employment Tribunals for breaking employment law and backdated wage claims, which cover a period of up to two years. Keeping track of leave entitlements and holiday pay is hard to do manually, which is why small businesses benefit from using leave management software designed for the UK.
CharlieHR is an ideal leave management tool for teams under 10, with affordable pricing, an easy to use interface, and features that go beyond time off management — including onboarding, performance reviews, and employee data and docs management. If you’re looking for a standalone leave management or rota management tool, consider Rotageek or Papershift.